Something a little different today. This is an introduction to a book I've written on How to Write Fiction. I've tried to sell it but the answers were always that I didn't have a name they could market.
#####################
I am approaching the heart of this book with two theses, both simple. The first is that good writing consists of mastering the fundamentals (vocabulary, grammar, the elements of style) and then filling the third level of your toolbox with the right instruments. The second is that while it is impossible to make a competent writer out of a bad writer, and while it is equally impossible to make a great writer out of a good one, it is possible, with lots of hard work, dedication and timely help, to make a good writer out of a merely competent one.
– Stephen King; On Writing
To Write or Not to Write?
Why does one write? I can imagine a host of answers but the one that fits me, and I am the only one I can answer for, is that I must. It's what I am; it's what I was created to do. It's what gets me out of bed in the morning and keeps me up at night. Many people have written on the art of writing, both good writers and bad. The consensus is that it is a need, a drive, an urge that must be obeyed or we are unhappy. If you are uncertain whether you are a writer, think how you would feel if you were to give up the notion forever. That should do it.
And if you are a writer, you probably know what it is you want to write. Or think you do. You have probably tried your hand at something or other by now, perhaps a poem or a diary, or perhaps you enjoy writing letters, a noble and dying art. However the Muse stings your hide, be assured that it is the real thing, for anything which whispers in your ear in the middle of the night, disturbs your dreams or otherwise coaxes your thoughts ever back to itself has undeniable reality. And if you ignore it, it will not go away, for it is your inner self rapping for attention and it will not be denied; if you would be happy in your life, obey it.
Trust your inner consciousness to know what it wants and to be right in that; you're just along for the ride. The still, small voice is that call to be yourself, to be what you were created to be and not to be afraid of that, though there be dragons lying in wait. We have been taught to be timid, to mistrust our instincts and ignore the inner voice as false and fantastical. Everyone has something to say and writing is the instrument both of self discovery and of the expression of that awakened self. All art is the expression of that elusive internal self; all creation is an act of bravery. Those who create are the life blood of the race. If you are a writer, count yourself among the blessed and get on with it.
And while everyone has something to say, and perhaps everyone does have a book in him or her, it does not mean to say that everyone is capable of writing that book. If you approach your writing from the outset with the idea that your goal is to become rich and famous à la Stephen King, you are extremely likely to be disappointed. On the other hand, if you have decided that you shouldn't write a word because you have no hope of becoming rich and famous, you are cheating yourself of one of the finer things that you can do with your life, which is to leave behind you a personal record, an archive, however well or poorly written. Never discount the value of leaving behind something real of yourself. Just think how valuable anything written by your great-grandmother is, even though it talked only of how she spent her afternoons. The danger is in thinking only in the short term, one of the many illnesses of Western civilization. No matter how long you inhabit the planet, your writing will live after you and be valued for as long as it exists, even if only by your descendants. You will become a revered ancestor.
The most essential gift for a good writer is a built-in, shockproof shit detector. This is the writer's radar and all great writers have had it… A writer without a sense of justice and of injustice would be better off editing the year book of a school for exceptional children than writing novels. – Ernest Hemingway
Never write for the market; write for yourself. If you believe in your story, that is what keeps you going. It is an act of faith to sit down at that computer without a map of where the story is going and that's when the creativity flows. It is common to pick up a book on writing which begins with tips on getting published, managing rejection and getting that salable idea, which is to put the cart before the horse. If your emphasis is on what is salable, what is marketable and what is not, then you are not a writer. A writer must write. Anything well-written is, in theory, salable. Concentrate first on learning to write well; the rest will follow.
The more I write to please myself, the more likelihood there is that I'll please other people in the process… The business of writing a novel becomes less of a source of anxiety and more a source of pleasure if we learn to concern ourselves with the writing process and less with the presumptive end product... – Lawrence Block, Telling Lies for Fun and Profit
First you must decide that this is who you are, not just something you do for a lark. Do not dabble. Ever. If you expect a reader to take you seriously, you have to have respect for yourself and what you are trying to do. Once you have come to believe it— no mean feat — the rest will come. You will make time, you will find that special place into which the Muse will venture boldly and not like a frightened deer that must be coaxed, minute by tedious minute. And you will learn how to be alone, for that is the state of the writer. Learn to love it. Which is not to say that you should not be a weekend writer, only that, whatever you write, take yourself seriously. If you don't believe in what you're doing, no-one else will believe in it either because that disrespect for yourself will communicate itself to the reader. It is not possible to fake it.
And write every single day. Stephen King told an interviewer that he took Christmas Day off but then admitted that he fibbed about it; he didn't want to look pathetic! If you only produce fifty usable words, it still keeps the story in your mind, the characters and their voices in your head and this is very important. If you must leave it for a while, you will find that you must re-read everything to reclaim the feel of it. Leave it long enough and you will lose that feel for good. At the very least, all your plans for your character may well have been forgotten.
Talent is an issue, but it is not everything; the urge to tell the story is. The form of the story does not matter to begin with. It will let you know how it wants to be written. Discipline is a central issue. If you can't get yourself seated in that chair, for all your brave thoughts and New Year's resolutions to Do It, it will not happen. Someone said that genius was largely the application of the seat of the pants to the seat of the chair. Believe it. Hemingway once wrote that getting caught up in the swamp of everyday life was merely a form of quitting.
Talent is very difficult to define in any art form. We know it exists; we know some people have it and others are devoid of it. Almost everyone has some talent for something. I may be a fine carpenter while understanding nothing of growing flowers. This is the easily recognized diversity of the human mind. When we speak of someone's being 'talented', it is often without thinking about what that means. It is not enough to be prolific to be talented, or voluble or charismatic with fans. Popularity is no gauge of real talent beyond the modest amount required to accomplish the task in acceptable fashion. Talent may be the ability to see things in ways no-one has ever seen them before; talent has a lot to do with understanding what works and what does not. Sculptors understand this best of all artists since it is essential to know exactly how much stone needs to be chiselled away — and no more. It is an indefinable quantity that shows only in the end product — or not.
Someone has said that great artists are all born with talent but that not one of them was born knowing how to do it. Good writing, like good painting or musical expression must be taught and is perfected only through practice. In her excellent book on learning to draw, Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain, Betty Edwards emphasizes her fundamental belief that everyone can be taught to draw, and draw well, that it is a matter of learning the techniques. The idea is sound; the techniques of good writing can also be taught. Even if you never become a literary sensation, you can learn the techniques well enough that whatever you write will be acceptable to all who read it. Beyond that, it is up to you and how faithfully you pay heed to the still, small voice. Talent may be what makes you great; technique is what will get you published.
The other thing you must do is educate yourself. Learn everything you have time to learn. All those chintzy little courses you took in college because you needed three extra credits or that soul-destroying job you took to pay the rent could turn out to be a goldmine. The more you know, the more you will understand of the human condition and that is the only subject in town. That's the game, the whole ball of wax. There is nothing else to write about simply because nothing else exists.
A good writer should know as near everything as possible. Naturally he will not… They are the very simplest things and because it takes a man's life to know them the little new that each man gets from life is very costly and the only heritage he has to leave. Every novel which is truly written contributes to the total knowledge which is there at the disposal of the next writer who comes, but the next writer must pay, always, a certain nominal percentage in experience to be able to understand and assimilate what is available as his birthright and what he must, in turn, take his departure from. – Ernest Hemingway,
Death in the AfternoonWhat is the best early training for a writer? An unhappy childhood. – Ernest Hemingway
This above all else: Do not expect to get it right the first time. Or the second, or the sixth. It is done when it is done and not before. If you can get this etched into the grey matter, you will almost never suffer from writer's block or from the tyranny of the blank page. And when you are stuck for what happens next or what to say next and feel like chucking it because you are never, ever going to get it right, remember that writing is hard. Take a bath, go to a movie, make love, fill your face, whatever it takes to make you happy and trust that your subconscious is working on it because that's what it does. Writing is not something that only happens when you are sitting in front of the computer or staring at a sheet of foolscap, clicking your teeth with a pencil and wondering what to have for dinner. If a writer is what you truly are, it is happening all the time and you must keep a notebook handy because the best ideas tend to burst into the conscious mind when you are in the bath or sitting on the pot or standing in the check-out line, any time your mind is relaxed and distracted.
As a beginning writer, you are inevitably going to make errors. We all make them. In fact, we all make much the same ones. They're fixable. Once you see the problem — and after you've finished slapping yourself on the forehead for it — you won't do it again. Eventually, you won't be a beginning writer any more and you can snicker yourself silly when you recognize the same blunders in others. It's perversely satisfying.
Try not to think of yourself as a writer, however; learn to think of yourself first and foremost as a storyteller and this applies to the writing of fiction and non-fiction alike. It keeps things in perspective. Story is what it's all about, story first, foremost and all there is. We tell each other stories all the time, whether it be a conversation, a letter or a chat with the hairdresser. Story is how we bond to each other, make friends and keep them, create our own identities as members of the human race. All forms of communication involving language are story.
In his fine book on screenwriting, Story: Substance, Structure, Style and the Principles of Screenwriting, Robert McKee says that, rather than being a form of escape from reality, story is what leads us down the road in our search for reality.
Kenneth Burke tells us, stories are equipment for living… Day after day we seek an answer to the ageless question Aristotle posed in Ethics: How should a human being lead his life?… Our appetite for story is a reflection of the profound human need to grasp the patterns of living, not merely as an intellectual exercise, but within a very personal, emotional experience. In the words of playwright Jean Anouilh, "Fiction gives life its form"… To retreat behind the notion that the audience simply wants to dump its troubles at the door and escape reality is a cowardly abandonment of the artist's responsibility. Story isn't a flight from reality but a vehicle that carries us on our search for reality, our best effort to make sense out of the anarchy of existence. – Robert McKee
In a television interview, British author Terry Pratchett said that when we look into the unknown and are frightened by it, story tells us that we are not alone in our fear. Story talks about what it might be like out there and, in sharing that story with another human being, we are both comforted.
But the art of the story is in decline. If the content of the story is not thoughtful, careful and accurate, the wrong things are learned, inappropriate attitudes are fostered and the damage is often well nigh irreversible. So long as we see literature — and well-written non-fiction has a strong element of the literary — as having no more than entertainment value, there is no compelling reason for accuracy, either of fact or of thought, no reason to use it to call attention to social ills or avoid unrealistic, fantastical, even silly themes. If the trend continues unchallenged, it will be the death of literature, both printed and visual, and art will be seen as valueless other than as set decoration to existence,
art
meaning all creative endeavour.
Television and cinema are visual literature, since they begin with the written word, the script. That most of it is pulp and pap is the fault of those who see it as purely entertainment, a medium for marketplace exploitation aimed at the mythical youth demographic and the message of that medium has suffered severely for it. Aristotle must be rolling in his grave. Yet it is also the fault of those who indulge in it, gobble it up like so much junk food for the mind, uncritically, never demanding anything better. Our educational systems have let us down by not teaching us what consitutes good literature, by no longer teaching us the essentials of language and culture, by not implanting shit detectors in each and every one of us. Hardly anyone knows any more what good writing looks like.
The purpose of story is the shedding of light on truth.For although an artist may, in his private life, lie to others, even to himself, when he creates he tells the truth; and in a world of lies and liars, an honest work of art is always an act of social responsibility. – Robert McKee
Nevertheless, as Mr. McKee says in his book, watching every movie ever made will not train you to write a script. Reading every novel ever written does not qualify you to write one, either. And watching television does not qualify you for anything other than the Golden Couch Potato Award. I have seen stories that were written exactly as if the writer had watched a great deal of television but never opened a book. There is next to no character development, no attention at all to point of view, the text consists almost entirely of cliché dialogue and the action is badly-written exposition that wouldn't excite a nervous pigeon. Before you can do it, you have to learn how it's done. If you are not willing to put yourself through that process — and then practise — pu down now. As Stephen King suggests, go and wash the car, make youself useful, because you will never be a writer.
On the other side of the coin, if you have never read a novel, you haven't a hope of producing one. And no, short stories are not short novels and are absolutely as difficult to write well. They just don't take as much time. And short story writers and novelists are two different animals; if you are truly drawn to the one medium rather than the other, stay with your choice. If, like almost all writers, you started writing by trying to write a short story, it doesn't mean that you should not try something longer as well. We walk before we can run. If you find your short stories wanting to grow, then let them. Never try to limit what is happening in your head; that way lies disaster, no matter what you're attempting.
All literature, including the spoken word, is story. All the rules apply, whether what you write is a poem, a play, a short story or a novel, fiction or non-fiction. Who is it for? Every personal record ever written – past, present and future – paints the human picture in fine detail, for we must have bards to sing our songs, to tell our story and say how we passed this way. And to say that we are just like you, you who read our story a thousand years from now.
Literary talent is not enough. If you cannot tell a story, all those beautiful images and subtleties of dialogue that you spent months and months perfecting are not worth the paper they're written on. What we create for the world, what it demands of us, is story. Now and forever. – Robert McKee
The image of the Roman arena distills the artistic process into one, vivid metaphor. The artist, the performer, the writer, anyone who does anything which thrusts him into the public eye, is out there on the sand, sword in hand, fighting for his continued existence, for the right to go on being what he was created to be in full view of everyone. But the crowd is a fickle suitor; it adores its darlings of the moment, screaming their praises and showering them with gifts but it is ever watchful for every flaw, ever vigilant for that crack in the armour that serves as proof that the hero is not a god but a human being, just like everyone else. But the crowd does not forgive; it will consider itself deceived and turn its thumbs down. Never write for the crowd. If you are determined to write, write for youself, write because you must. Write because it is who you are.
Respect. Respect your readers, respect your characters, both real and fictional, and respect yourself.
It is all about respect.
It is all about telling the truth.
It is all about love.
What Do You Want to Write About?
You know that fiction, prose rather, is possibly the roughest trade of all in writing. You do not have the reference, the old important reference. You have the sheet of blank paper, the pencil, and the obligation to invent truer than things can be true. You have to take what is not palpable and make it completely palpable and also have it seem normal and so that it can become a part of the experience of the person who reads it. – Ernest Hemingway
What are you going to write? What you write and how you write it is determined to a large extent by your audience. Family, friends, a newspaper, a magazine, a book, the internet — it matters who is going to read it. You will write very differently on exactly the same subject for Aunt Martha from the way you would write for an anonymous member of the crowd and we have all experienced having to write for the teacher. Consider what you want to talk about and then give some thought to the form in which you wish to express the ideas, and consider them all. Perhaps Grandma's story is best done as a biography, if her whole life was unusual and of interest outside the family, or perhaps some particular story from her life is best told by itself. Should it be biographical narrative or could it be explored as a short story, a poem, or even something long? And consider that the story of any member of the family, including yourself, however it is written, will stand as a part of the family archive, something to be treasured by future generations. This is an immensely powerful reason for writing. It is completely valid to write for the sake of doing it without thought of finding a publisher. If you see it that way, then it is entirely possible that the freedom it gives you as you write, the peace of mind, will make your writing much truer, even much better and what better gift can you give your descendants than a record of a life?
The usual wisdom is to write what you know, which is to state the case with such simplicity as to border on the silly. That is usually interpreted to mean,
What is your personal experience?
Which is fine. The failure, for beginning writers, is to think that they have so little experience that there is nothing worth writing about. My friend and I both find this rather amusing: she was in Cameroon as a Peace Corps volunteer and I have lived and worked in the Canadian Arctic and we both find that to be ordinary, neither really believing that what was everyday life for us could possibly be of any interest to anyone else.
It serves to illustrate a point. We have all said that a good actor can have us laughing and crying just by reading the telephone directory. To repeat what so many others have said, it is not so much what you say as how you say it. What we all want – what we all crave – is a glimpse into the life of another human being, another journeyer on the lonely path, to reassure ourselves that we are not alone, that our experiences are not that different or weird or tragic, that others have survived the Hero's Journey and that belonging to the human race consists of more than being equipped with bipedal locomotion and opposable thumbs. We have all been there, done that, and it isn't so bad after all if we can have company on the road.
The good parts of a book may be only something a writer is lucky enough to overhear or it may be the wreck of his whole damn life – and one is as good as the other… Forget your personal tragedy. We are all bitched from the start and you especially have to be hurt like hell before you can write seriously. But when you get the damned hurt use it — don't cheat with it. Be as faithful to it as a scientist — but don't think anything is of any importance because it happens to you or anyone belonging to you.
– Ernest Hemingway
What you write about is trivial compared to what your character, and ultimately your reader, can learn from it. Which is not to say that reading about doing the dishes or warming baby food isn't going to make your reader yawn. What your reader wants to know is how you felt about pacing the floor in the wee hours while your husband snored — or how you felt when he did it for you and even fetched you hot milk because you'd had a hard day. It's the common humanity that you bring to your writing which makes it readable, enjoyable, moving, instructive — which makes it literature. Make your writing part of the human experience and you cannot fail to have readers. This is done through characterization, through tone and sound, through subtext, through introspection, point of view — through writing on the back of your eyelids
.
Much of it, language, spelling, vocabulary, sentence structure, logical progression of story line, happens in the left brain; you can learn to mobilize the right brain for the rest of it. Engage the senses, all six of them! What do you see, hear, smell? What is the texture of the night or the taste of the wind? What do you feel?
Where do you get your ideas?
Did you look at the sky this morning? Did you notice the people at the line-up in the bank? On the bus? Herding children through the mall? Did you listen to someone's tale of trying to find a parking space or the way to Pete's Frootique? Do you remember your honeymoon or having your first child? Do you listen to others? The point here is that everything is a story. The essence of the story is the wonder that life generates in all its aspects, light and dark, sacred and mundane. Learn to listen – to others, to yourself, to the rhythms of living — and you will never want for stories.
On a more practical level, the first source of story is your own life, your own experience. Fiction writers often use the 'what if?' approach, starting with a common occurrence and teasing it out to a conclusion. It works.
In truly good writing no matter how many times you read it you do not know how it is done. That is because there is a mystery in all great writing and that mystery does not dis-sect out. It continues and it is always valid. Each time you re-read you see or learn something new.
– Ernest Hemingway
I must admit to not knowing what the process is. Sometimes it seems to be a matter of spontaneous mental combustion, although I am quite certain that it is not. How do you prod the process into life? A good start is to read. A writer must read. Voluminously. Anybody and everybody. Don't be afraid of material which makes you squirm. Some things are meant to make us uncomfortable. Schindler's List makes me desperately uncomfortable, as does A Tale of Two Cities. Be brave. There will be times when your own writing makes you uncomfortable but you must never shy away from where the story needs to go. That it makes you uncomfortable is a mark of your own humanity.
You see it's awfully hard to talk or write about your own stuff because if it is any good you yourself know about how good it is – but if you say so yourself you feel like a shit.
– Ernest Hemingway
Read whenever you have a free moment, on the bus, in the waiting room, in the park, everywhere. Turn off the television and reacquaint yourself with the printed page. Once you begin to write, you will read differently. You will read more critically, looking for content, technical mastery, turn of phrase and vocabulary, moving description and beauty of style. The subject matter becomes almost incidental.
My personal feeling is that story is character-generated and character-driven. Character first; story happens. Plot? What the heck is a plot? More of that later, as well. Michael Caine has said that he feels that, when he portrays a character, it is not so much copying behaviour as holding up a mirror for others to see themselves. This is what the great novelists do.
And before you complain that you wanted to write poetry, not a story, let me repeat, in case you missed it the first time around: All literature, including the spoken word, is story. You are a character in the story, especially the poem. No writer so divorces himself from his work that he is not in it himself. Even in fiction, the writer becomes the narrator, whether the story is written in the first person or not. In non-fiction, the writer is the central character. The whole purpose of most non-fiction is the expression of the personal experience and understanding of the author; it cannot be otherwise. The most successful non-fiction —which includes, of course, memoirs and autobiographies — is written very personally. The Diary of Anne Franck would be so very much less effective, even given the horrendous subject matter, if it had not been, centrally, a personal story. Reporting does not work. The highest non-fictional literature is the personal, inner journey, the soul journey, the Hero's Journey. It is at its best when approached as story.
What to put in or leave out? Everything, every word, every phrase, every paragraph, must advance the story in some way. If it does not fill out a character, add to the understanding of story or setting, to the ambience and mood, it does not belong there and must be left out.
And that's it.
Judith